Governance, Organizational and Financial Review
Cosgrove & Co. conducted a review of an organization licensed and funded by the province to deliver social services on its behalf. Allegations against a senior leader had brought long-standing tensions to a critical moment.
SECTOR
Non-profit organization, licensed & funded by government
Size
30 employees + 50+ service recipients impacted
Pathway
Diagnose → Gaining Clarity on the Issues
Engagement
Three months; 2023
01
The Situation
A government department received workplace allegations involving an organization it funded and licensed.
Â
Long-standing concerns had escalated into a public battle between board and staff, placing service recipients at potential risk, and all parties in a difficult situation.
Â
The department needed an independent, confidential assessment before deciding how to respond.
02
Our Process
Rather than treating the public complaint as the full picture, we treated it as a starting point for a broader diagnostic review of what was actually happening inside the organization.
Â
We supplemented our usual review team with a seasoned workplace investigator, and partnered with a national audit and assurance firm to provide a rigorous, defensible process.Â
Â
Applying independent thinking, professional judgement and a sound process, we looked at:
-
The realities of the situation, not the speculation - data, facts, evidence
-
How and why the current situation came to be - understanding the historical context, but grounding in today's compliance obligations and client needs
-
What to do about it now - what does 'better' looks like, and is it achievable?
Â
The diagnostic process was long and robust, generally including:
-
Confidential interviews of board, staff and department representatives
-
Walk-in, no appointment sessions open to key stakeholders who wanted to talk to us
-
Review of the legislation, governing documents, licensing and funding agreements
-
Review of the governance, HR and financial policies and processes
-
Examination of the allegation, communications, board minutes and other confidential records
-
Sampling of financial records, receipts, invoices, and interviews with the bookkeeper to understand how finances were handledÂ
-
Final report with our observations and analysis, advice to the department, and a set of practical recommendations for improving the organization’s effectiveness, applied to a three-year implementation roadmap.
Â
The workplace investigation resulted in a confidential report to the department as a separate deliverable in this engagement.
03
The Outcome
What initially looked like an HR, leadership or financial problem, was revealed to be a loss of confidence that compounded over time. It started with a bad situation three decades earlier from which the organization never truly recovered.
​
Naming that clearly gave the department (and the volunteer board) relief and genuine clarity. It became an opportunity to open a constructive discussion about how change needs to be made, in order to move forward together as service delivery partners.